President Donald Trump’s $45,000 cash gifts to three of his closest aides were never gifts at all but an illegal supplement to their federal salaries, according to Richard Painter, who served as chief White House ethics lawyer under President George W. Bush. His assessment, published on Wednesday, September 9, 2026, is one the White House rejects.
Painter told Newsweek the payments break federal law and could carry consequences for the president himself: “President Trump could get himself impeached for it.”
What Painter offers is a lawyer’s opinion — not a court ruling, and not a proceeding. No impeachment article has been filed over the payments, no committee has opened an inquiry, and the Justice Department has taken no public action. Legal specialists are split on whether the statute covers the money.
What the Disclosure Forms Show
Natalie Harp, executive assistant to the president, reported a “Cash gift for the holidays” worth $45,000 from Trump. Communications adviser Margo Martin used the same words, and Chamberlain Harris, deputy director of Oval Office operations, wrote “Cash Gift for Holidays.” Walt Nauta, director of Oval Office operations, listed a “Gift for holidays” of $20,000, bringing the four to $155,000. The Washington Post reported the payments on September 8.
The scale drew attention. Harp, Martin and Harris each earn $150,000 a year, by the White House’s own personnel report to Congress, so $45,000 equals 30 percent of a salary. Nauta is paid $175,000, leaving his $20,000 gift at about 11 percent of his pay.
The four forms cover 2025 and were released this month. Filers must disclose gifts from a single source totaling more than $480. The same filings show the aides had earlier been paid by Trump’s transition operation, by Save America or by his 2024 campaign.
All three women had worked for Trump long before this administration. His political operation took on Harp, 35, in 2022; she earned the nickname “the human printer” during the 2024 campaign by hauling a portable printer everywhere he went. Martin and Harris both served in the first term and returned in 2025.
The Law at the Center of It
Painter points to a 1962 law, 18 U.S.C. Section 209, “Salary of Government officials and employees payable only by United States.” Executive branch employees generally may not accept compensation, or a salary supplement, from any source but the federal government in return for their government work; pension and insurance plans run by a former employer are carved out. A dispute comes down to one question: was the money compensation for government service, or was it given for some other reason?
A former boss who hands a longtime employee a large sum after that employee joins the government is paying salary, Painter argues. “Employers and employees don’t have gift-giving relationships,” he told Newsweek. “If your employer gives you $50,000 at the end of the year, that’s not a gift, that is salary.” Both sides are exposed — “the employee and the person who makes the payments could be criminally charged” — and he put the statute of limitations at five years.
No one has been charged, so any penalty is hypothetical. They sit in a companion provision, Section 216: a fine or up to one year in prison, five when willful, plus civil penalties. The Supreme Court narrowed the statute in 1990, holding in a case over Boeing severance paid to executives leaving for federal jobs that Section 209 does not reach money handed over before the recipient joins the government. These four were already on the payroll.
The White House Pushes Back
A White House statement said: “The President has a longstanding practice of giving Christmas gifts to people in his orbit, including at times employees and aides, both in government and in his time in the private sector. The gifts at issue here have nothing to do with any of these individuals’ official government duties, and therefore are entirely permissible under relevant legal and ethical standards.”
Other specialists land in between. Dave Aronberg, formerly the state attorney in Palm Beach County, said $45,000 “is a lot different from giving someone a Christmas sweater or a bottle of wine.” John Ronquillo, an associate professor at the University of Maryland School of Public Policy, told CNN the amounts demand explaining. “It’s not a trivial amount and so that should raise red flags for a lot of people, you know, who are watchdogs, who are ethics experts in terms of why, why is this happening,” he said.
Two Complaints Land in a Week
The argument did not stay an opinion for long. The Campaign Legal Center wrote to the Office of Government Ethics on September 10, asking acting director Keith Sonderling to investigate whether White House employees “accepted cash payments from the President in violation of criminal law and if so, refer the matter to the Department of Justice.” Sonderling has led the office in an acting capacity only since June, while also serving as acting labor secretary.
A day later the Democracy Defenders Fund demanded a criminal investigation in a letter to prosecutors signed by Painter, a former associate counsel to President George W. Bush; Virginia Canter, who served as ethics adviser to President Bill Clinton; and Norman Eisen, who held the same ethics post under President Barack Obama. It went to U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro and the Justice Department’s acting public integrity chief, Edward Sullivan. Neither office had responded publicly as of September 18. The group’s statement said the payments “effectively boosted staffers’ compensation to $195,000, effectively matching the salary rate of the president’s most senior advisors,” and argued Trump structured them “to close the gap in pay,” which it says appears to violate 18 U.S.C. § 209.
Eisen, co-founder and executive chair of Democracy Defenders Fund, said in the statement: “Trump’s no stranger to using his position to line the pockets of his most loyal allies, but this crosses a very clear line.” Painter added: “In the last 18 months we have probably had more violations of ethics rules than in the earlier eight years combined. This appears to be yet another.”
What Impeachment Would Require
Impeachment is a political process, not a prosecution. The House can impeach with a simple majority; conviction takes two-thirds of the Senate. Republicans hold 218 seats to the Democratic caucus’ 214, with one independent and two vacancies, and voters decide all 435 on November 3. Rep. Al Green forced a vote on impeachment articles on September 15, which the House tabled 232-147; that resolution concerned immigration enforcement, not the payments. Trump was impeached in December 2019 and again in January 2021, and acquitted both times.
Painter is not a disinterested observer. He held the ethics job from 2005 to 2007, teaches at the University of Minnesota Law School and is vice chair of Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington. He left the Republican Party, ran twice as a Democrat in Minnesota and joined a 2017 CREW suit accusing Trump of violating the foreign emoluments clause.







