Bush’s Ugly Trump Painting Ignites Uproar

A portrait of President Donald Trump exists somewhere in former President George W. Bush’s studio, and journalist Jacob Weisberg says no one is allowed near it. Bush has “painted a really ugly picture of Trump, which he won’t show to anybody,” Weisberg said in an interview with New York magazine’s Intelligencer, reported on September 15, 2026.

The remark came in a conversation with Michael Calderone, deputy editor of Intelligencer, about Weisberg’s book “Profiles in Cowardice: A Study of Collaboration in the Trump Era,” which Penguin Press published September 15. Weisberg built the “Bushisms” series around Bush’s verbal stumbles in office. He now faults the only living former Republican president for his silence, arguing that Bush has done too little to confront Trump — and profiling him as one of the book’s eight subjects.

Readers got the Bush chapter before they got the book. The New Yorker ran an excerpt on September 1 under the title “George W. Bush’s Code of Silence,” ahead of publication.

Another of the book’s subjects has since gotten the same treatment. The New York Review of Books published Weisberg’s essay on Dartmouth president Sian Beilock, titled “The Dartmouth Exception,” in its September 24, 2026 issue, under a page title reading “Dartmouth Fails the Test.” The standfirst lays out the charge: “Among its peers in the Ivy League, Dartmouth was perfectly positioned to resist Trump’s attack on higher education. It chose not to.”

Art Therapy in the Post-Presidency

Painting became Bush’s pursuit once he left the White House, and in Weisberg’s telling the brush now does the job a microphone would. “He’s expressing all of his feelings through painting, this kind of art therapy,” Weisberg said. Bush paints wounded veterans and immigrants, he said — a way of engaging with politics without ever stating his views explicitly.

Weisberg likened the hidden Trump portrait to “The Picture of Dorian Gray.” The canvases, in his reading, hold what Bush actually thinks, since nothing he has said out loud does. Other former presidents have commented on Trump’s policies from time to time, Weisberg noted, and Bush had the same opening and the same obligation — but he will not say Trump’s name. He hides instead, Weisberg said, behind the notion that former presidents must remove themselves entirely from commenting. Bush’s rapport with his Democratic counterparts, ideological differences aside, appears far warmer than anything he has with Trump.

Eight Collaborators, From McConnell to Bezos

Weisberg casts the eight public figures he profiles as collaborators who helped return Trump to power and entrench him there. Among them are former Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, Chief Justice John Roberts and Sian Beilock, the president of Dartmouth, with the cast drawn from law firms, universities, courts and Congress. Beilock championed sweeping anti-racism initiatives as president of Barnard College during Trump’s first administration, New York Times columnist Michelle Goldberg noted, and as Dartmouth’s president in his second term “has kept mostly mum about Trump’s attacks on higher education.” Also among the subjects is Blackstone co-founder Stephen Schwarzman, whom Goldberg described as a “vulture capitalist” and grouped with McConnell and Megyn Kelly as figures whose failure she found unsurprising.

In the New York Review of Books essay, Weisberg grounds the Dartmouth argument in the college’s own history, opening with Trustees of Dartmouth College v. Woodward. He recounts that Dartmouth was founded in 1769 under a royal charter from King George III, that the New Hampshire legislature passed a law in 1816 aimed at converting it into a state-run university, and that college officer William H. Woodward defected with the financial records, college seal and legal authority before the trustees sued to regain control.

The law firm Paul Weiss and its then chairman, Brad Karp, open the book. The president targeted the firm, and in March 2025 Karp signed on to a deal whose terms included $40 million worth of pro bono representation for causes Trump backs. Karp, the only one of the eight who agreed to be interviewed, had held out for five days. He “made a disastrous decision in agreeing to make a deal with the White House after only five days,” Weisberg said. Karp resigned the chairmanship in February 2026, though he remains a partner.

That capitulation marked a reversal. During Trump’s first administration, Goldberg reported, Karp assigned 75 lawyers at Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison to fight Trump’s family separation policy.

Weisberg also profiles Megyn Kelly, who endorsed Trump in 2024 after challenging him over his history of misogyny in 2016, and Amazon founder Jeff Bezos, who killed the Washington Post’s endorsement of Kamala Harris that year and overhauled the paper’s Opinion section. Weisberg says his aim is to understand these choices rather than simply condemn them.

In a broadcast interview aired September 14, Weisberg drew a line around what he means by the word in his title, telling NPR’s Morning Edition host Steve Inskeep that the failing he describes is a specific kind. “I’m talking about civic cowardice,” he said. His targets are not people who “oppose Trump’s politics,” he said, but people who failed to push back on what he called “Trump’s dictatorial behavior, his governing by emergency decree and executive order.” Inskeep raised the book’s reach with him: “You’ve got head of a Democratic or liberal-leaning law firm. You’ve got prominent Republicans. And you also have a university president, the president of Dartmouth. Who is she, and what’s the story?”

Appearing on PBS’s “Amanpour & Company” in a segment aired September 17, 2026, Weisberg traced the book to the contrast he saw between Trump’s two terms. “I got the idea right early in Trump’s second term because I was so aware of the difference from his first term,” he said. “In the first term I felt the guard rails protecting democracy mostly held. They were a little shaky but they held.”

Sins of Omission

Weisberg does not want Bush to be a full-time critic, and he said nobody expects ex-presidents to respond to every development. Bush’s quiet, though, belongs to a specific category of failure in his telling. “There’s sins of commission and sins of omission,” Weisberg told Calderone, putting Bush’s reluctance to criticize Trump publicly in the second column. He tied that silence to Trump having “dismantled USAID,” the agency that helped run PEPFAR, the global HIV/AIDS program Bush launched.

The reviews have kept coming, and not all of them are persuaded. Russ Smith of Splice Today published pushback on September 16 in a piece titled “George W. Bush Takes a Long Breather,” calling Weisberg’s case about the 43rd president unconvincing, while allowing that Weisberg, unlike many of his peers, is not overly obnoxious in print about his dislike of Trump. Others have taken the book up as ammunition. A Cleveland.com opinion column published around September 20, 2026 invoked it while arguing about vaccine policy, calling it Weisberg’s “tremendous new book” and adding, “In an age of Donald Trump’s tyranny, we are surrounded by sellouts.” A second wave followed. Goldberg, writing September 19, called it “Jacob Weisberg’s important new book” but added, “Some of Weisberg’s choices perplexed me; a few of the figures he focuses on are less morally compromised than simply rotten.” Another review paired the book with one by Anthony Scaramucci, summarizing the two as offering “two visions of America in retreat.”

Bush has not responded to the book, and his office has not commented on the portrait. As for the canvas, Weisberg says Bush keeps it exactly where he has always kept it: out of sight.

Recent Articles

Country Western Style Display

Young Country Singer Dead at 22 in Crash

The crowd that watched CJ Beach play a waterfront bar in Panacea, Fla., turned out to be the last to hear him sing. Beach, a...
CBS Logo on Tablet

Trump’s “60 Minutes” Meltdown Shocks CBS Host

A “60 Minutes” hypothetical put paradise within reach of President Donald Trump on a single condition — that he forgive the enemies he has...
jimmy kimmel (1)

Kimmel’s Blunt Two-Word Trump Message Electrifies Crowd

Late-night host Jimmy Kimmel answered the president’s explanation for his party’s midterm collapse with two words, and his studio audience did the rest. Kimmel, 58,...
Donald and Melania Trump

Melania Booed Mercilessly at Football Game

Melania Trump brought a $7.2 million scholarship announcement to Baton Rouge, and the Tiger Stadium crowd answered with boos. Fans at Louisiana State University’s Tiger...

Bear Attack Kills Mother and Daughter

A mother and daughter set out for a short walk on a trail they had hiked many times before, a few minutes from their...

More Articles Like This