A federal judge has partially blocked President Donald Trump’s second attempt to narrow birthright citizenship. Sitting in Greenbelt, Maryland, U.S. District Judge Deborah Boardman granted a preliminary injunction on Wednesday, September 2, 2026, in the case known as CASA v. Trump. Under her ruling, the administration may not deny citizenship to a class of children the Supreme Court has already found to be citizens.
The relief has limits. Agencies may not enforce the new policy against the children the case covers, but they remain free to keep developing internal guidance for carrying it out if it ever takes effect.
Any children who would have been denied citizenship under Trump’s first executive order fall inside the lawsuit’s certified class. Coverage extends to children born after February 19, 2025, including those born in the future. Under the injunction, the State Department, the Department of Homeland Security and the Social Security Administration, among other agencies, may not take any step to interfere with, deny or refuse to recognize those children’s citizenship.
A Sharp Rebuke From the Bench
Boardman, an appointee of President Joe Biden, spent 35 pages treating the August policy as an effort to sidestep a decision the justices had already handed down. “No Presidential Executive Order can undo what the Supreme Court has done,” she wrote, adding that Trump v. Barbara “is the law of the land. The President must follow it.”
Boardman also concluded, on the merits, that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on their claim that the new policy violates the 14th Amendment’s Citizenship Clause. “The 2026 Executive Order is almost certainly unconstitutional as applied to the certified class for the simple reason that the Supreme Court in Barbara already decided that the children in the class are citizens at birth,” she wrote in the opinion. A facial declaration of unconstitutionality would be premature, she stressed.
The chief justice had confined the narrow set of exceptions recognized by the Supreme Court to the children of foreign diplomats and to members of sovereign tribal nations, she noted, and those exceptions bear no resemblance to the carveouts written into the August orders.
She faulted their breadth as well. Buying a plane ticket counts as a commercial transaction, she noted, and a parent who took part in one is treated as having traveled to the United States to obtain citizenship for a child. The plaintiffs fear that parents could be labeled alien enemies and their children denied citizenship as a result; she found that fear credible, pointing to the administration’s record of accusing Venezuelan nationals of ties to the criminal organization Tren de Aragua in deportation proceedings, often without evidence. Vagueness, she added, runs through the orders on the questions of whom they cover and whether they operate retroactively or only going forward.
A Different Answer Five Days Earlier
Five days before the injunction, Boardman had declined to act. On Friday, August 28, she voiced concern about the new policy but would not grant immediate relief that day. “As far as I can tell, this is unprecedented,” she said of it. The plaintiffs are the immigrant services group CASA, the Asylum Seeker Advocacy Project and several individual members of the two nonprofits who have given birth in the United States since the litigation began in 2025. She directed them to challenge the August orders in a revised complaint, and said a briefing schedule would follow.
The Administration Responds
“This is just another ruling from an activist judge appointed by Biden attempting to thwart President Trump’s commonsense agenda,” White House spokeswoman Lauren Bis said. “The birthright citizenship executive order is consistent with the holdings and analysis set forth by the Supreme Court.”
U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche, speaking to Fox News on Wednesday night, said the government had never expected this judge to rule its way and was not caught off guard. “If we have to go back to the Supreme Court, we will,” Blanche said.
How the Dispute Got Here
Trump signed his first birthright citizenship order on January 20, 2025, the opening day of his second term. It barred agencies from issuing citizenship documents to children whose parents were unlawfully present in the country or whose presence was lawful but temporary, and set an effective date 30 days later that never arrived. Boardman blocked that first order too, with a preliminary injunction in February 2025, and Judge Joseph Laplante of the District of New Hampshire issued a class-wide injunction against it on July 10 of that year.
The Supreme Court struck that order down on June 30, 2026, in Trump v. Barbara. Children born in the United States to parents unlawfully or temporarily present are subject to the jurisdiction of the United States and are citizens at birth, Chief Justice John Roberts wrote for the majority, joined by Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, Amy Coney Barrett and Ketanji Brown Jackson. The judgment ran 6-3, but the constitutional holding commanded only five votes: Justice Brett Kavanaugh agreed the order had to fall while arguing it violated a statute rather than the Constitution. Justice Clarence Thomas dissented, joined by Justice Neil Gorsuch; Justice Samuel Alito and Gorsuch each filed dissents of their own.
On August 6, in the Oval Office, Trump signed two replacement orders, “Continuing to Protect the Meaning and Value of American Citizenship” and “Ending Birth Tourism.” The first instructs agencies not to recognize the citizenship of children of noncitizen parents when either parent is an alien enemy, a foreign government employee, or party to a commercial transaction involving birth, including surrogacy. It reaches the children of foreign embassy staff and of employees of international organizations such as the United Nations and World Bank, and it excludes children born in territories where no federal statute confers citizenship — in practice American Samoa and Swains Island, whose residents are U.S. nationals rather than citizens.
A second challenge to the August policy remains pending in New Hampshire. For the children in the Maryland class, the policy stays on hold while the litigation continues.







