A woman who waited tables in a Sausalito restaurant more than half a century ago now holds a $59.25 million judgment against Bill Cosby, and she says she wants him behind bars until he opens his books.
A contempt request now sits before a judge of the Los Angeles County Superior Court, filed by Donna Motsinger, the onetime waitress from Northern California who won that verdict in the spring. She wants Cosby, the 89-year-old comedian, held in contempt for ignoring an order to disclose his finances, according to court documents reported Nov. 12, 2026. She says she has received no money, no bank statements and no answers to the court’s written questions since a jury found Cosby liable on March 23 for drugging and sexually assaulting her in 1972.
Her filing does not hedge. Cosby’s “noncompliance is not partial, late, or excusable. It is total,” her filing states.
The Asset Answers That Never Came
Judge Bradley S. Phillips ordered Cosby on Oct. 9 to provide verified answers, without objection, to written questions about his assets, and the same order imposed $1,560 in sanctions payable to Motsinger’s lawyers. Phillips gave him 10 days, setting a deadline of Oct. 19.
Nothing arrived, according to Motsinger. She says Cosby has disclosed no bank accounts, no income and no other holdings since the verdict.
The court should summon Cosby to account for his refusal in person, the filing argues, and should order his arrest should he fail to appear. Motsinger seeks $3,284 in attorney’s fees and costs, along with five days in jail and fines of up to $1,000 for every violation. If the court finds him in contempt and he still refuses, she wants him held until he turns over the information.
Phillips has not ruled on the contempt request, and no arrest warrant has been issued. The hearing is scheduled for January 2027.
Not Jail for the Debt Itself
Joshua Wurtzel, an attorney at Schlam Stone & Dolan, called a warrant a “real possibility” — but not over the unpaid money. “Courts typically are not able to jail people for unpaid civil debts,” Wurtzel said.
Wurtzel framed contempt as both a serious threat to Cosby and a lever to force compliance. The exposure comes from the order he is accused of ignoring, not from the size of the judgment.
What Phillips demanded amounts to the substance of a debtor’s exam: a full accounting of Cosby’s assets and where they sit, covering accounts, investments, real estate, business interests and income. Under California law, a judge can order a debtor to show cause, and if the debtor is personally served and fails to appear, the court can direct the sheriff to bring him in. A contempt finding can mean detention until he answers. A warrant would be considerably harder to carry out if Cosby is outside California.
Three Depositions He Did Not Attend
Other courtrooms have waited for Cosby too. A separate federal case brought by 10 women in Nevada produced three depositions in April, June and September that he did not attend, according to reporting attributed to the accusers’ lawyers. His attorney has cited legal blindness, limited mobility and age-related health problems.
Jennifer Bonjean, Cosby’s attorney, said recently that his health has taken a turn for the worse, describing him as blind, mobility impaired and allegedly requiring an assistant to help him at depositions, as of Nov. 10. She has said her client does not leave home and is in poor health.
Jesse Creed, Motsinger’s attorney, tells it differently. The comedian looked sharp and healthy when he sat for a deposition in November 2025, Creed says, and he accuses Cosby of hiding assets — an allegation, not a finding. Another attorney in the Nevada matter has asked a federal judge to compel Cosby’s deposition or enter a default judgment.
A Pill, a Glass of Wine
Motsinger, 84, worked as a waitress at the Trident, a restaurant in Sausalito, Calif., in 1972, the year Cosby came to the area to record a stand-up performance at a nearby theater. She testified that wine and a pill left her without awareness. Her complaint says she went in and out of consciousness, and she has alleged she woke up with her clothes stripped after being given wine and pills.
The case reached a jury because California reopened a window for sexual assault claims that had expired under old time limits. Compensatory damages came to $19.25 million in the jury’s award, split between $17.5 million for past mental trauma and $1.75 million for future mental suffering — plus $40 million in punitive damages, one of the largest civil awards against him. Motsinger is one of more than 60 women who have accused Cosby of misconduct.
“This verdict is not just about me—it’s about finally being heard and holding Mr. Cosby accountable,” Motsinger said through her lawyers after the verdict. “I have carried the weight of what happened to me for more than 50 years. It never goes away.”
A former spokesperson for Cosby said the verdict left him “deeply saddened,” and called it a dangerous precedent “to allow decade-old allegations, presented without evidence or proof, to stand.”
From Jane Doe to Plaintiff
Andrea Constand’s 2005 civil case against Cosby drew testimony from anonymous Jane Does, Motsinger among them. Pennsylvania prosecutors built his only criminal conviction on Constand’s allegations in 2018. The state Supreme Court threw out that conviction in 2021 over a violated prosecutorial agreement, by which point he had served more than two years of a three-to-10-year sentence. A 2022 civil case ended with damages for another accuser.
Bonjean told jurors at trial that a punitive award was not a question of deterrence. Cosby had been denied a fair trial, she said afterward, arguing that a defendant has no real way to answer claims that reach back half a century.
Phillips rejected a bid for a new trial in May, finding no irregularity that made the trial unfair. An appeal is pending. Cosby has denied every allegation of nonconsensual sexual contact and maintains his innocence.







